Skip to main content
Peer-Reviewed Clinical ResearchZero Sponsor Bias

SodaTide Review: A Synbiotic Capsule With Doses Far Below Trial Amounts

Supplement Safety
Fact-checked by the SupplementDecoded Research Editorial Team

SodaTide Review: A Synbiotic Capsule With Doses Far Below Trial Amounts

Last reviewed:
·
5 min read
·Fact-checked by the SupplementDecoded Research Editorial Team·Reviewed by SupplementDecoded Research Editorial Team
SodaTide bottle, 30 capsules, metabolic and digestive support
Table of Contents
Show Chapters

Medical Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional before starting any new supplement regimen.

Read our Medical / Expert Review Policy and Medical Disclaimer for details.

Key takeaways: SodaTide is a once-daily synbiotic capsule whose label is unusually open about its amounts, and that openness is what sinks its claims. The label lists chicory root inulin at 211 mg, potato resistant starch at 100 mg, and a three-strain probiotic blend at 36 mg in total, with no strain codes and no CFU count. The resistant starch trial that supports the gut-weight idea used 40 grams per day, which is 400 times the 100 mg in this capsule. The Akkermansia trial used 10 billion bacteria per day, a count SodaTide never gives. Trustpilot reviewers for the seller's store, at 1.6 out of 5 across 27 reviews checked on October 28, 2026, report overwhelmingly the same story: no weight change, refund refusals or partial refunds, and upsell charges they did not expect. Pricing is $158, $207, and $294 for 2, 3, and 6 bottles, with a 30-minute countdown timer and six digital bonuses on larger tiers. No FDA or FTC action naming SodaTide was found as of October 28, 2026, and no independent, peer-reviewed test of SodaTide was found. A company-announced single-lot test is detailed in the expert section, and it does not change that conclusion.

Contents

The verdict

SodaTide deserves credit for one thing most funnel products refuse to do: it prints its amounts. The label image on the reviewed page lists every active ingredient with a milligram figure, and the three-strain probiotic blend is named strain by strain. That transparency makes the verdict possible, and the verdict is not kind.

The amounts are tiny against the trials they borrow from. Resistant starch at 100 mg is one four-hundredth of the 40 grams per day used in the best human weight loss trial. Inulin at 211 mg is a fraction of a gram, while inulin trials work in grams, often 10 grams or more. The probiotic blend totals 36 mg across three strains, with no CFU count, so it cannot be compared to the 10 billion bacteria per day used in the Akkermansia pilot trial at all.

The buyer record points the same way as the dose math. Trustpilot reviewers report no weight change after one to three months, refund requests met with a 20 percent restocking fee or with partial-refund offers, and checkout upsells that added hundreds of dollars. The Supplement Decoded Team does not recommend SodaTide for weight loss, appetite control, blood sugar control, or gut rebalancing.

Talk to your doctor: weight gain after menopause, diabetes, thyroid problems, and medication effects all need a medical check first. A synbiotic capsule is not a substitute for that check, and it is not a substitute for the food, movement, and sleep changes that actually move weight.

Specifications

ItemDetail
BrandSodaTide
FormCapsules, 1 per day, 30 capsules per bottle
Serving size1 capsule, 30 servings per container
Label activesChicory root inulin 211 mg, potato resistant starch 100 mg, probiotic blend 36 mg (total 347 mg)
Distributor (from the label)Instituto Experience, Lakeland, FL 33804, +1 (507) 448-8190, [email protected]
Contact (from the sales page)Email [email protected]; SMS support +1 (855) 889-3137
Price range$158 (2 bottles) to $294 (6 bottles); $79, $69, and $49 per bottle
Guarantee60 days headlined; sales page says from purchase date after 30 days of use, Returns page counts from delivery in one step and purchase date in another; buyers report a 20 percent restocking fee not stated on the sales page
Where soldOnline only; transaction handling reported as BuyGoods in buyer reports

What is SodaTide?

SodaTide is a once-daily capsule pitched as a natural way to support a better functioning metabolism and promote healthy weight loss. The bottle front reads "Advanced Metabolic Science" and "Metabolic and Digestive Support", with claims for appetite control and satiety and for energy production from fats.

The mechanism story is gut bacteria. The page says the formula directly attacks harmful bacteria that sabotage weight loss and promotes good bacteria that activate fat burning. It says prebiotic fibers feed good bacteria, while probiotic strains rebalance the gut microbiome, improve insulin sensitivity, and optimize hunger and satiety signals.

That story is plausible as biology and weak as a product claim. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health notes that different probiotic strains may have different effects, and that a result for one strain does not transfer to another strain, or even to another product with the same species. SodaTide names its strains but gives no strain codes and no CFU count, so no strain result can be transferred to it with confidence.

One name, two formulas

Buyers should know that the name SodaTide does not buy one formula everywhere it appears. The reviewed label and most secondary pages agree on one formula: inulin 211 mg, resistant starch 100 mg, and a 36 mg blend of Bifidobacterium infantis, Clostridium butyricum, and Akkermansia muciniphila, with no strain codes and no CFU count.

A marketplace version described by ScamAdviser is different in every probiotic respect. It reports a total of 6.8 billion CFU across Lactobacillus acidophilus, Lactobacillus plantarum, and Lactobacillus paracasei, with no individual strain amounts. Not one strain overlaps with the reviewed label, and the CFU total cannot be checked against the reviewed label at all, because the reviewed label states no CFU figure.

Rating claims conflict just as sharply. One sales page claims 4.9 out of 5 from more than 23,400 happy customers. Another claims 4.8 out of 5 from 2,400 plus reviews. The independent Trustpilot profile for the seller's store shows 1.6 out of 5 across 27 reviews at the time of this check, with the overwhelming majority critical. Those numbers cannot all describe the same verified buyer pool, and the independent platform is the one that can actually be checked.

The practical consequence is plain. A buyer cannot reliably know which probiotic strains ship from the name alone, and a review of one SodaTide formula is not a review of the other. Check the Supplement Facts panel on the bottle you actually receive against the panel in this review before trusting any claim made about the name.

Who sells it: the company check

The distributor named on the label is Instituto Experience, Lakeland, FL 33804, with phone +1 (507) 448-8190 and email [email protected]. That phone number and email address are familiar from earlier products in the same seller family, including SodaSlim, whose page uses the same pricing tiers and the same legal-page host.

The footer legal pages live on a different domain, under the name Instituto Experience, with a Brazilian locale. That is the same legal-page host used by the SodaSlim and MemoHoney pages reviewed earlier, and the contact page there lists the same SMS number, +1 (855) 889-3137, and the same email address as the SodaTide page.

The template reuse is visible inside the legal pages themselves. The Returns page is titled for Eagle Labs, a different name from both SodaTide and Instituto Experience. The Terms page says testimonials are exceptional results that do not reflect the typical purchaser, which matches the sales page's own admission that testimonial names were changed to protect privacy.

One template leftover on the sales page is harder to miss. Just above the third pricing block, the page urges buyers not to waste time before ordering, but it names a different product in that sentence, calling it a LeanBurn order. A page that cannot keep its own product name straight in its urgency copy was not proofread for this product, and buyers should read its other claims with that in mind.

Readers should also know how many buyers say they arrived. Trustpilot reviewers repeatedly describe video ads featuring a fake Dr. Oz and a fake Oprah Winfrey promoting a baking soda trick, and a secondary investigation by MalwareTips reaches the same conclusion: the advertised baking soda story and the capsule formula do not line up, because the formula contains no baking soda. No regulator finding is cited here, because none was found, but the pattern across independent buyer reports is consistent and it is reported as buyer and secondary-source reporting, not as a proven fact about every ad.

Secondary pages report further, conflicting operator signals that could not be verified on the reviewed page itself: one secondary review says a Terms page names GEX Corporation LLP as site owner, another reports a returns address in Largo, Florida, and a company press release uses a Denver, Colorado address. Those signals are reported here as secondary reports, not as verified facts, because they point in different directions and none of them appears on the reviewed page. A buyer therefore cannot settle, from the sales material alone, which legal entity stands behind an order.

Transparency, in short, is mixed. The label itself is more open than most funnel labels, but the seller behind it is a name on a label image and an email address, with no founder, no factory address, and no About page, and the legal pages that govern refunds were written as generic templates for other products.

What the ads claim, and what the evidence says

The reviewed page makes no disease claim in the strict sense, and it carries the standard disclaimer that the statements have not been evaluated by the FDA and the product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Its weight loss claims are still strong, and they are tested below against trusted sources.

Claim (from the reviewed page)What the evidence actually saysGrade
It directly attacks harmful bacteria that sabotage weight lossNo trial of SodaTide exists, and the page names no harmful bacterium and no strain that attacks it. The claim cannot be tested at all.F: no product evidence
Prebiotic fibers feed good bacteria, prolong fullness, and reduce glucose spikesInulin and resistant starch are real prebiotic fibers. The resistant starch trial in 37 adults with overweight or obesity used 40 grams per day for 8 weeks and found a mean 2.8 kg loss. SodaTide gives 100 mg, one four-hundredth of that amount.F: dose is 1/400 of the trial dose
Probiotic strains transform the gut into a fat-burning machineThe NIH Office of Dietary Supplements states it is unclear whether probiotic supplements have any effect on weight or body fat. Probiotic effects are strain specific, and SodaTide gives no strain codes and no CFU count.F: no strain code, no CFU, no transfer
Akkermansia muciniphila, linked in studies to a healthy metabolism, helps process food more efficientlyA 2019 pilot trial gave 10 billion Akkermansia bacteria daily for 3 months to 32 overweight or obese insulin-resistant adults. Insulin sensitivity improved, but the weight change, minus 2.27 kg against placebo, was not statistically significant. SodaTide states no Akkermansia amount and no CFU total for its blend.D: real pilot trial, no dose, weight result not significant
Produced in the USA in an FDA-registered facility, rigorously tested for quality and safetyFDA does not approve dietary supplements before marketing, and facility registration is not product approval. No tester, certificate, or lot result is named, so the testing claim is unverifiable.Misleading if read as approval

Ingredients

The label names three active groups and no others. Every amount is printed, so every amount can be checked. The check is the problem.

  • Chicory root inulin, 211 mg. A prebiotic fiber that feeds gut bacteria. Inulin trials for weight loss work in gram-level amounts, with results mixed even at those amounts. At 211 mg, SodaTide gives a small fraction of a gram-level trial amount, so no inulin trial can be applied to this capsule.
  • Potato resistant starch, 100 mg. A starch that reaches the intestine intact and ferments there. The best human trial, a randomized crossover in 37 adults with overweight or obesity, gave 40 grams of resistant starch per day for 8 weeks and found a mean 2.8 kg weight loss and improved insulin resistance, linked to gut microbiota changes. SodaTide gives 100 mg, which is 0.1 grams, or one four-hundredth of the trial amount.
  • Probiotic blend, 36 mg total. Bifidobacterium infantis, Clostridium butyricum, and Akkermansia muciniphila, with no strain codes, no per-strain amounts, and no CFU count. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements notes many probiotic supplements contain 1 to 10 billion CFU per dose, with some containing 50 billion or more, and that higher counts are not necessarily more effective. SodaTide gives buyers no count at all, and a milligram weight for bacteria does not convert to a CFU count, so the blend cannot be matched to any probiotic trial.

The page also says the capsules are 100 percent vegetarian and lactose-free, and that the product must be refrigerated after opening to preserve probiotic potency. Refrigeration advice is consistent with live probiotics, but it also raises a question the page never answers: how many live organisms survive to the end of a 30-day bottle, and how is that verified? No CFU-through-expiration figure is given.

Illustration of a single capsule beside a magnifying glass over a blank label

Supplement label breakdown

The label is printed as an image on the reviewed page, which is why a text-only read can miss it. Read as an image, it is complete on amounts and thin on the details that matter for probiotics.

SodaTide Supplement Facts label showing inulin 211 mg, resistant starch 100 mg, and a 36 mg probiotic blend
IngredientLabel doseTrial dose or findingGap
Chicory root inulin211 mg per dayInulin trials use grams per day, often 10 to 30 grams, with mixed weight resultsSmall fraction of gram-level trial amounts
Potato resistant starch100 mg per dayResistant starch trial: 40 grams per day, 8 weeks, 37 adults, mean minus 2.8 kg1/400 of the trial amount
Probiotic blend (3 strains)36 mg total, no CFU, no strain codesAkkermansia pilot: 10 billion bacteria per day, 3 months, 32 adults, weight change not significantCannot be compared: no CFU, no per-strain amount

The label also carries a real caution that buyers should heed. It says pregnant or nursing mothers, children under 18, and people with a known medical condition should consult a physician before use, and it says not to exceed the recommended dose. Other ingredients are hypromellose (the vegetarian capsule), microcrystalline cellulose, magnesium stearate, and silica, all standard and inactive.

For readers checking their own medicines, the SupplementDecoded supplement interactions guide covers the general questions to ask a pharmacist before adding any new supplement, and the supplement dosage guide explains why a printed amount is only useful when it can be compared to a trial amount. SodaTide's label passes the first test, printing amounts, and fails the second, because its amounts sit far below every trial it borrows from.

Real reviews and complaints

We checked each platform separately. The results are unusually clear, because one independent platform carries a large, recent, and overwhelmingly critical record, while the other platforms carry nothing comparable.

Trustpilot: the main record, and it is critical. The Trustpilot profile for the seller's store shows 1.6 out of 5 across 27 reviews at the time of this check on October 28, 2026, with reviews dated September and October 2026. The reviews are listed as unprompted, not as verified purchases, so they are reported here as buyer reports, not as verified transactions, but the pattern across them is consistent and it is weighted, as the protocol requires, toward the critical reports.

  • No effect after weeks or months (critical, most common). Reviewers report a full bottle, or one to three months of daily use, with no weight change, no change in belly size, and no change in clothes fit, including one reviewer who walked 2 miles daily and watched carbs and fat and still recorded no pound changed in two weeks.
  • Refund refused, delayed, or cut (critical). Multiple reviewers inside the 60-day window report no reply to refund emails, refusal to refund, or a 20 percent restocking fee that turns a full refund into a partial one. One reviewer reports being offered 30, 40, 50, 60, and then 70 percent back while keeping the product, but never a full refund, and another reports being told a refund would keep $168 of the amount spent.
  • Upsells and extra charges (critical). Reviewers report a phone call within minutes of ordering pressuring an additional purchase, a checkout flow that added a second order, and totals far above the advertised tier price, including one report of more than $600 in total charges and another of $2,577.33 Canadian debited after a 6-bottle order. These are individual reports, not verified transactions, but they recur across separate reviewers and dates.
  • Fake celebrity ads (critical). Several reviewers say they bought because of video ads featuring Dr. Oz and Oprah Winfrey, then concluded the ads were fake. One reviewer also reports dizziness and very low blood pressure after use, and says they ordered from Amazon. That side-effect report is a single anecdote, not evidence that the product causes those effects, and it is included only because it is the kind of report a buyer should discuss with a clinician.

Other platforms: no comparable record found. A site-restricted Reddit search returned no results for SodaTide. No BBB profile or BBB complaint record for SodaTide surfaced in search. No genuine Amazon listing with a review pool was identified, only the single Trustpilot reviewer who says they ordered from Amazon. Facebook, Instagram, and X carry no independent buyer review pool found in search; the Facebook mentions found are the fake-celebrity video ads themselves, which are marketing, not buyer reviews.

Seller-page positives: marketing, not quoted as buyer experience. Seller and affiliate pages claim 4.8 out of 5 from 2,400 plus reviews, and another claims 4.9 out of 5 from more than 23,400 customers, with named testimonials reporting 14 to 31 pounds lost. Those pages name no platform, link no review pool, and contradict both each other and the independent Trustpilot profile, so they are classified as marketing and are not quoted here as buyer experience. The honest summary of the independent mix is therefore stark: on the one platform with a checkable record, the mix is overwhelmingly critical, and on every other platform checked, there is no independent mix at all.

Expert views: has anyone actually tested this product?

No, not in the sense that matters. No independent, peer-reviewed lab test of SodaTide was found, and no finished-product clinical trial of SodaTide was found. One company-announced test does exist, and it must be reported accurately rather than ignored. An October 6, 2026 company press release says an unopened sample from production lot ST-260817-B was sent to an unnamed laboratory accredited to ISO/IEC 17025, with testing completed September 8, 2026, and reports measured amounts close to the label (inulin 215.3 mg against 211 mg declared, resistant starch 102.1 mg against 100 mg, probiotic blend 36.8 mg against 36 mg), with heavy metals below quantitation, specified pathogens not detected, and no undeclared pharmaceutical compounds detected.

That release does not close the testing gap. The laboratory is not named, no certificate or report number is published with it, the blend is measured by weight in milligrams rather than by viable cell count, so no CFU result is given for any strain, and only one lot is covered. A composition and contaminant check on one lot is not a human efficacy trial, and it does not reconcile the other lot references found on retail pages. The same release also reports a September customer survey in which 94.1 percent of respondents rated their experience good or excellent, which conflicts sharply with the 1.6 out of 5 Trustpilot profile. Different samples and different recruitment can explain part of a gap, but the gap itself must be disclosed, not averaged away. The page's claim that ingredients are rigorously tested for quality and safety, without naming a tester or publishing a certificate, remains a marketing claim, not a verifiable test.

Category testing is the context, and it must not be mistaken for a test of this product. A 2018 JAMA Network Open analysis found 776 adulterated supplement products, mostly for sexual enhancement, weight loss, and muscle building. A 2014 JAMA analysis found that two thirds of recalled supplements with hidden drugs were still adulterated after recall. A 2024 JAMA analysis of galantamine products found 9 of 10 outside 10 percent of the labeled amount and 3 of 10 contaminated with bacteria.

Those studies tested other products, not SodaTide, and they are cited here only to explain why an untested product with no certificate deserves skepticism. They do not prove anything about this bottle, in either direction. Probiotic products carry an extra version of this risk: NCCIH notes some probiotic products have been found to contain microorganisms other than those listed on the label, and in some instances those contaminants may pose serious health risks.

Named expert positions point the same way as the trials. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements states it is unclear whether probiotic supplements affect weight or body fat. NCCIH states different probiotic strains may have different effects, and a result for one strain does not transfer to another. The FDA has warned health care providers about severe, potentially fatal infections in premature infants given probiotics, a warning about a vulnerable population, not about healthy adults, but a reminder that live microorganisms are not automatically risk free.

Older adult talking with a pharmacist at a pharmacy counter about a supplement bottle

Price, packages, and the guarantee

Prices are visible on the reviewed page itself, with a struck-through anchor of $179 per bottle behind every tier. There is no single-bottle tier.

PackageTotalPer bottleShippingCost per day
2 bottles, 60-day supply$158$79Plus shipping (amount not stated on the sales page)$2.63 before shipping
3 bottles, 90-day supply$207$69Free US shipping$2.30
6 bottles, 180-day supply$294$49Free US shipping$1.63

The "YOU SAVE" figures are anchor-minus-sale arithmetic: $200, $330, and $780. Every pricing block carries a 30-minute countdown timer that restarts on a fresh page load, and the page says 96 percent of customers order six bottles. That figure has no methodology, no time period, and no source, and it should be read as sales copy, not as buyer data.

Six digital bonuses come with 3-bottle and 6-bottle orders: sleep, metabolism, facial rejuvenation, gut flora, a 10-day metabolic challenge, and a personalized usage guide, with stated values from $39 to $77. Digital bonuses cost the seller nothing per buyer, and they should not be counted as value against the capsule price.

The page says the purchase is a one-time order with no automatic renewals, hidden fees, or surprise charges, and no subscription term was visible on the sales page. Later checkout steps were not opened, because reaching them requires clicking a purchase button, so any upsell or subscription term that appears only at checkout is not covered by this review, and Trustpilot reviewers report exactly that kind of checkout upsell.

The guarantee is where the page stops being simple. The headline promises a 60-day satisfaction guarantee, and the sales page says it runs from the date of purchase, but only after at least 30 days of use. The Returns page says in its opening line that returns are allowed within 60 days of the original purchase date, then in its first step says to make sure you are still in the 60-day period starting with the day the order was delivered. A buyer who waits for delivery, then uses the product for the required 30 days, can be inside one version of the window and outside the other.

The Returns page also requires emailing support with "Refund Request" in the subject line and following support instructions, and it says a refund takes several business days after approval. It states no restocking fee, no return-shipping payer, and no return address. Trustpilot buyers, by contrast, report a 20 percent restocking fee and partial-refund offers, neither of which appears on the sales page. That gap between the written terms and the reported practice is itself a finding, and buyers should get any refund promise in writing before ordering. The 6-bottle tier is a 180-day supply sold under a 60-day guarantee, so most of the largest pack sits outside the refund window by design.

Potential side effects

Probiotics and prebiotic fibers are generally tolerated by healthy adults, but they are not side-effect free. NCCIH notes prebiotics in large doses, more than 20 grams per day for an adult, can cause gassiness, bloating, abdominal pain, cramps, and diarrhea, and that probiotics can cause mild gastrointestinal effects in the first days of use.

Because SodaTide's fiber amounts are small, those dose-related effects are less likely from the fiber itself, but the probiotic blend has no CFU count, so a buyer cannot judge its likely gastrointestinal effect against any trial. The page itself warns pregnant or nursing women, people under 18, and people with a known medical condition to show the label to a doctor first, which is sound advice and, now that the label amounts are known, possible to follow.

People with weakened immune systems, critical illness, or central venous catheters should not start a live-microorganism product without medical advice. NCCIH notes the risk of harmful effects from probiotics is greater in people with severe illnesses or compromised immune systems, and the FDA has warned providers about severe infections in premature infants given probiotics. One Trustpilot reviewer reports dizziness and low blood pressure, which is an anecdote, not a proven side effect, and anyone with those symptoms after starting a new supplement should contact a clinician promptly.

Who should avoid it

  • Anyone who needs to know what they are taking. If you take prescription medicines, manage diabetes or blood sugar, or have a gut condition, a product with no strain codes and no CFU count gives your clinician only part of what is needed to check against your medicines or condition.
  • People with weakened immune systems, critical illness, or a central line. Live probiotics carry infection risk in these groups, and the decision belongs with a clinician, not a sales page.
  • Anyone buying for a specific result on a deadline. The trials behind the ingredient story measured small changes over 8 to 12 weeks, with diet and lifestyle controls, and SodaTide itself has no trial at all. A 60-day guarantee that requires 30 days of use first leaves little room to judge a result before the window closes.
  • Anyone who wants a verified product. No independent test, no certificate, and no named tester means there is nothing to verify except the bottle photo and the label amounts, and those amounts sit far below trial doses.

Conclusion

SodaTide is a rare funnel product that prints its amounts, and that honesty makes its case worse, not better. A 347 mg capsule with 211 mg of inulin, 100 mg of resistant starch, and a 36 mg probiotic blend cannot borrow results from trials that used 40 grams of resistant starch, grams of inulin, or 10 billion bacteria per day. The dose gaps are not close calls. They are factors of fifty to four hundred.

For $158 to $294, plus shipping on the smallest tier, a buyer gets 60 to 180 days of a capsule whose probiotic potency is unstated, under a guarantee whose own pages disagree on the start date and whose buyers report restocking fees the sales page never mentions, from a seller that names no company beyond a label distributor line. The countdown timer, the 96 percent claim, and the six digital bonuses are sales pressure, not evidence.

Readers who want gut health support have cheaper, checkable options: fiber-rich foods, fermented foods with live cultures, and, where a supplement is wanted, a product with named strains with codes, a CFU count through expiration, and a third-party certificate. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you take medicines or have a medical condition, and bring the label with you. With SodaTide, the label is now known, and it is reason enough to pass. A related cautionary example in the same seller family is the SodaSlim review, where a different formula was sold under the same pricing tiers and the same legal-page templates.

Sources

Review note: SodaTide is reviewed as a supplement product, not as a web page. Product details, label amounts, prices, and terms were taken from the seller's sales page, its label image, and its footer legal pages as of October 28, 2026; prices and offers can change. Variant sweep: 20 distinct pages examined (the reviewed page plus 19 confirmed distinct secondary pages, including a syndicated label guide counted once across three mirrors and a September 2026 launch release), with a further 9 domains listed in a forum post but not individually verified. No OfferVault or Affplus listing for SodaTide was found in public search, and no network was named on the pages examined except BuyGoods as checkout processor. The seller page is research material only and is not linked here.

Fact-checked by the SupplementDecoded Research Editorial Team

Subscribe to the Science

Get the latest evidence-based research and supplement guides delivered directly to your inbox.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

Share This Scientific Review

“Knowledge is meant to be shared.”